Boy Butter Comfort Cream vs. Desensitizing Formula: How They Differ and When to Use Each

Quick answer

If you want a smooth, gentle glide without numbing, go with Boy Butter Comfort Cream. If you're seeking to manage premature ejaculation or increase comfort during penetration, the Desensitizing Formula with Benzocaine is the better pick. The right choice depends on your sensitivity and goals.

Choosing between Boy Butter Comfort Cream and the Desensitizing Formula comes down to what you want from your lubricant. Both are designed to enhance pleasure, but they work differently. Comfort Cream focuses on silky, long-lasting moisture, while the Desensitizing Formula adds a numbing effect to help you last longer and reduce discomfort.

Understanding the trade-off is key. Desensitizing lube can be a game-changer for some, but it isn't for everyone. In this guide, we break down the differences so you can decide which one fits your needs.

What Sets Boy Butter Comfort Cream Apart

Boy Butter Comfort Cream, like the H2O Formula, is a water-based cream that combines Vitamin E and Shea Butter for a smooth, skin-friendly glide. It's designed to mimic natural moisture and is safe to use with toys and latex condoms. Because it's water-based, it washes off easily and is gentle enough for daily use.

This type of lube is ideal when you want comfort without any numbing sensations. It's also a good option for those with sensitive skin who prefer a hypoallergenic, non-irritating formula. The creamy texture provides lasting lubrication without being sticky, making it a versatile choice for many activities.

• Water-based and latex-safe
• Contains Vitamin E and Shea Butter for skin comfort
• No numbing effect; preserves natural sensation

What Makes the Desensitizing Formula Different

The Desensitizing Formula, such as Boy Butter Extreme, contains 5% Benzocaine, a local anesthetic that numbs the area to reduce sensitivity. This can help manage premature ejaculation or make penetration more comfortable if you're especially sensitive. The effect is temporary and localized, allowing you to extend your session.

However, the numbing effect also reduces sensation for you and potentially your partner. It's not ideal if you want to feel every touch. Also, because it's a stronger formula, it's better to start with a small amount to see how your body reacts. The trade-off is enhanced endurance at the cost of some feeling.

• Contains 5% Benzocaine for numbing
• Helps with premature ejaculation and penetration comfort
• Reduces sensation; start with a small amount

How to Choose Between Them

Think about your primary goal. If you want a comfortable, natural-feeling lube that won't interfere with sensation, Comfort Cream is your match. It's great for everyday use, with toys, and with partners who are sensitive to numbing agents.

If you want to last longer or find penetration uncomfortable due to sensitivity, the Desensitizing Formula can be a helpful solution. Just be aware of the trade-off: you'll feel less. It's also important to communicate with your partner if you use it together, so everyone knows what to expect.

Trade-offs to consider

• Sensation: Comfort Cream preserves natural feeling, while Desensitizing Formula numbs to reduce sensitivity. Choose based on whether you want full sensation or need to reduce it.
• Intended use: Comfort Cream is great for everyday play, including with toys and condoms. Desensitizing is specifically for lasting longer or easing penetration discomfort. Match the lube to your primary activity.
• Partner experience: Desensitizing lube can affect your partner's sensation too. Comfort Cream is shared-friendly without numbing effects. If you play with a partner, discuss whether numbing is welcome.

Product facts at a glance

• Boy Butter H2O Formula 8 oz: The formula is creamy and goes on clear, is toy safe, latex safe, vaginally safe, and edible. Boy Butter H20 is long-lasting, gentle, washable, and eventually absorbs into the skin. This is a solid example of a comfort cream that prioritizes safety and versatility, making it suitable for most users without numbing effects.
• Lube Tube ~ Boy Butter Extreme Desensitizing Formula 6 oz: Boy Butter Extreme is a desensitizing lubricant made with 5% Benzocaine, a local anesthetic. These Ingredients are homogenized like real butter and the end result is a personal lubricant that will numb the fun parts and last as long as any synthetic or silicone lubricant. The Benzocaine provides the numbing effect that helps with premature ejaculation and penetration comfort, but it also reduces sensation—the key trade-off.

Who should choose which?

Best for

• Those who want a gentle, natural glide without numbing—choose Comfort Cream
• Those seeking to manage premature ejaculation or reduce discomfort during penetration—choose Desensitizing Formula

Not for

• If you want full sensation and no numbing, avoid the Desensitizing Formula
• If you need to reduce sensitivity significantly, the Comfort Cream won't provide that effect

Both Boy Butter Comfort Cream and the Desensitizing Formula have their place. Think about your priorities—sensation or endurance—and choose accordingly. Always start with a small amount of any lube to see how it feels, and enjoy the experience.