Boy Butter Original vs. Desensitizing Formula: Which One Should You Choose?

Quick Answer

Choose Boy Butter Original if you want a thick, long-lasting glide with easy cleanup. Choose the Desensitizing Formula if you need numbing to manage discomfort or premature ejaculation. Both are from Boy Butter, but they serve very different purposes.

When you're standing in the lube aisle—or scrolling online—the choice between Boy Butter Original and the Desensitizing Formula can feel confusing. Both come from the same trusted brand, but they're designed for different experiences. Understanding the core difference helps you pick the one that matches your goals.

This comparison breaks down what each formula does, who it's for, and the trade-offs you should know before buying.

What Makes Boy Butter Original Stand Out?

Boy Butter Original is an oil-based, water-soluble personal lubricant. It's whipped with coconut oil and shea butter, giving it a thick, creamy texture that lasts. The water-soluble cleanup means you don't have to scrub or use harsh soaps—warm water rinses it away from skin and fabric.

This formula is ideal for longer sessions because it doesn't dry out quickly. The creamy consistency provides a cushiony glide that many find comfortable for both solo and partner play. It's a solid choice if you want a reliable, long-lasting lubricant without any numbing effects.

• Thick, creamy texture that stays put
• Water-soluble for easy cleanup
• No numbing ingredients—full sensation preserved

What Does the Desensitizing Formula Do Differently?

Boy Butter Extreme Desensitizing Formula contains 5% Benzocaine, a local anesthetic. This ingredient numbs the area to help reduce discomfort during penetration and may help manage premature ejaculation. It's homogenized like real butter, so it has a smooth, consistent texture similar to the Original formula.

The numbing effect is the key difference. If you're exploring anal play or need extra endurance, this formula can help you push past initial sensitivity. However, it's not for everyone—if you want to feel everything, this isn't the choice.

• Contains 5% Benzocaine for numbing
• Helps with discomfort and premature ejaculation
• Smooth, homogenized texture

Key Differences at a Glance

The main difference is sensation. Original preserves full feeling, while Desensitizing reduces it. Texture-wise, both are creamy, but Original relies on oils for glide, while Desensitizing adds an anesthetic.

Cleanup is similar—both are water-soluble, so you won't struggle with sticky residue. But the choice really comes down to your goal: do you want lasting glide or numbing endurance?

• Original: full sensation, long-lasting glide
• Desensitizing: numbing effect, helps with endurance
• Both are water-soluble for easy cleanup

Trade-Offs to Consider

• Sensation: Original keeps full feeling; Desensitizing numbs. If you want to feel every touch, Original is the way. If you need to dial down sensitivity, Desensitizing helps. Decide how much sensation you want before choosing.
• Purpose: Original is for general lubrication and longer sessions. Desensitizing is specifically for discomfort or premature ejaculation. It's not a daily-use lube for everyone. Match the formula to your primary goal.
• Cleanup: Both are water-soluble, so cleanup is easy. But Original's oil-based nature might leave a slightly different feel on the skin compared to the Desensitizing formula. Both wash off easily, so you don't have to compromise on cleanup.

Product Facts

• Boy Butter XL Oil Based Water Soluble Personal Lubricant | 25 oz Squeeze Bottle: Whipped to perfection with a sophisticated blend of coconut oil and shea butter, this creamy personal lubricant delivers a thick, luxurious glide. It's oil-based yet water-soluble for easy cleanup. You get the longevity of an oil-based lube without the hassle of stubborn cleanup. Great for extended sessions where you don't want to reapply.
• Lube Tube ~ Boy Butter Extreme Desensitizing Formula 6 oz: Made with 5% Benzocaine, a local anesthetic. These ingredients are homogenized like real butter, resulting in a personal lubricant that numbs the fun parts and lasts as long as any synthetic or silicone lubricant. The numbing effect can help you manage discomfort or premature ejaculation, making it a targeted choice for those specific needs.

Which One Fits You?

Best for

• Those who want a long-lasting, creamy lube without numbing effects
• People who prefer full sensation during play and need easy cleanup

Not for

• Those who need numbing to manage discomfort or premature ejaculation—choose the Desensitizing Formula instead
• Anyone who wants to feel every sensation—Desensitizing will reduce feeling

In the end, the choice between Boy Butter Original and Desensitizing Formula comes down to what you want from your play. Original delivers a thick, lasting glide with full sensation. Desensitizing adds a numbing effect to help with endurance or discomfort. Pick the one that matches your needs, and you'll get a reliable, water-soluble lube that performs.